Data Center Backlash: AI Firms Rewrite the Pitch, Keep the Plans

Voters restricted data centers across 10 states on November 3. The companies building them have answered with new names, fewer NDAs and a friendlier story about power, while the gigawatt counts stay where they were.

On Wednesday, November 4, the day after the US midterms, Meta president Dina Powell McCormick told a Wall Street Journal tech conference what the results meant for her company's construction pipeline. "I think it's going to be harder," she said of building data centers, and she conceded the industry had "not done as good a job as we needed to explain the benefits of these investments." Then she described the footprint: data centers in 23 states, with five planned projects of 1 gigawatt or more. She did not say any of them would shrink.
That pairing sums up the industry's first answer to the data center backlash. Voters in 10 states faced 45 local ballot measures on the facilities, and by early Wednesday, Engadget reported, 33 restrictions had passed with six more projected to follow. In Urbana and Hubbard, Ohio, outright bans won with 76 and 77 percent. Since then the companies building AI infrastructure have changed how they talk to the towns around their sites. They have left the megawatts alone.
OpenAI's week of new language
OpenAI moved fastest. On November 1, two days before the election, chief global affairs officer Chris Lehane told Axios the company was preparing a post-election "PR blitz" and floated renaming data centers "AI compute campuses." A day later it took its Grid Protectors Program national, built around a planned campus in Effingham County, Georgia, that could give up as much as 1,000 megawatts during extreme weather or emergencies. By November 6 it had also pledged to stop using NDAs with public officials on data center projects, ending a practice that kept local officials from telling residents what was being negotiated. All of this lands while OpenAI is raising money at a $1.25 trillion valuation, a poor moment for a siting fight in every county.
The Georgia piece deserves a closer look, because it shows how much of this is repackaging. According to TechTarget, the 1,000-megawatt figure comes from a 25-year agreement with Georgia Power that was announced in July and went through the state's regulatory approval in August. The campus is expected to need about 3,200 megawatts. What changed in November was the label on the arrangement and the promise to repeat it elsewhere. Georgia Power declined to say when it can call on the reduction or how the reduction will be measured.
The NDA retreat began before anyone voted
It would be tidy to say the election caused all this. The record says otherwise. TechCrunch noted on October 31, three days before the vote, that the backlash had already prompted Amazon and Microsoft to promise to stop using NDAs. Companies saw the opposition building and moved early, and the ballot measures confirmed they had read it correctly.
Politicians made the same calculation. In Michigan's 7th District, The Intercept reported, Republican incumbent Tom Barrett proposed banning local officials from signing NDAs with developers as his race tightened. He lost anyway to Will Lawrence, a Democrat who campaigned on a moratorium on new data center development. When a sitting Republican and OpenAI arrive at the same concession within weeks of each other, the NDA has become a practice nobody will defend.
Powell McCormick described what Meta thinks a workable project looks like now. The company pays for its own electricity, tax surpluses from the site go to teachers and first responders, and the workforce is local. Those are terms of entry. None of them limits size.
The megawatts did not move
Look at what was announced in the nine days after the vote.
On November 6, Crusoe confirmed it had sold an unfinished project in southeastern Wyoming to Google, which said it would invest $17 billion in the campus. The reported reason for the handover was Google's concern about cost and schedule under Crusoe, and the site was conceived to scale to 10 gigawatts. Google's infrastructure bill had grown two days earlier as well, when the company announced $15 billion for data center projects in Malaysia.
Anthropic, which has mostly rented its computing, was reported on November 9 to be spending $3.4 billion on natural gas turbines capable of producing up to 1.7 gigawatts. On November 12, Nebius laid out $40 billion in planned spending for 2027. Washington is still pushing the same way: a conditional $5 billion Energy Department loan reported on October 28 would add 1.1 gigawatts at eight nuclear plants, and most of the new output at seven of them has already been bought by Google, Meta or Amazon.
So the first half of the argument holds. No company with a large pipeline has cut it in response to the vote.
If the fight is about electricity, a new name won't settle it
The second half, that better manners will buy peace, is much shakier. In MIT Technology Review on November 9, James O'Donnell argued that the backlash is at root about electricity and that it comes in two forms. A data center on the grid raises the question of who pays for power and transmission. One that generates its own power, usually with gas turbines, raises the question of who breathes the exhaust. He called the two problems "neither easily solved by public relations." Virginia activist Elena Schlossberg put it more bluntly: "It was always about power."
The courts are making the same point. On October 31 a federal judge refused to dismiss an NAACP lawsuit accusing xAI of running at least 35 combustion turbines at its Colossus site near Memphis without air permits. In Vineland, New Jersey, the operator of a site Nebius depends on was fined $1.1 million over unpermitted gas generators, and Nebius now says capacity promised to Microsoft will arrive months late. An NDA policy does nothing about a turbine, and Anthropic has just bought a great many of them.
There are other reasons to doubt the thesis. One is that parts of the industry do not accept the premise. Adam Kovacevich, who runs the tech-backed trade group Chamber of Progress, warned against confusing "an anti-Trump wave with an anti-tech mandate." Lehane wrote two days after the vote that data centers "have become a proxy for public unease about affordability, corporate power" and people's sense of control over their futures. If the diagnosis is unease, messaging looks like the cure, and messaging is what the industry has delivered.
Another is that neighbors may not be the binding constraint at all. Developers told O'Donnell that insiders see their ambitions as "constrained less by public opposition than by a lack of electricity." SoftBank reported a $7.1 billion quarterly loss on November 10, more than half of it tied to power-generating equipment it had over-ordered. TechCrunch's Equity podcast spent its November 11 episode on the possibility that many announced projects never get built. If pipelines do shrink in 2027, financing and turbine queues may deserve more of the credit than voters.
A last option is to skip persuasion entirely. O'Donnell expects self-powered sites to drift toward places like the Permian Basin, where few people live nearby, and Elon Musk mused hours after the results that data centers in space looked appealing. Going abroad is not frictionless either. In Thurrock, England, an insect conservation charity and a speedway club have both lodged objections to a Google data centre planned on a former raceway.
What would prove this wrong
Texas is the first test. Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa supports a statewide moratorium, and even outgoing governor Greg Abbott directed a state regulator on September 21 to halt data center permits. If a project like Stargate Frontier in Shackelford County, projected at 1,820 megawatts, is delayed or resized by the state, then the buildout is no longer intact and the companies will have more to revise than vocabulary.
Congress is the second. Once the new session is sworn in on January 3, a nationwide moratorium bill from Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Martin Heinrich's GRID Savings Act, which would keep grid costs from being passed to communities, will show whether the vote translates into federal rules.
The third test is local and slower. An NBC exit poll cited by TechCrunch found almost 80% of respondents against data centers in their own neighborhoods. If restrictions keep passing in places where developers showed up without NDAs and with a promise to pay their own power bills, the conclusion will be hard to avoid: manners were never the problem, and the next concession will have to be measured in megawatts.
Sources
- Americans overwhelmingly voted against data centers in the midterms (Engadget)
- OpenAI might rebrand its data centers as 'AI compute campuses' (TechCrunch)
- Meta warns that election backlash against data centers could make AI expansion harder (TechCrunch)
- Crusoe sells troubled Wyoming data center project to Google (TechCrunch)
- Anthropic joins AI's natural gas frenzy, buys $3.4B worth of turbines (TechCrunch)
- The backlash about data centers might really just be about electricity (MIT Technology Review)
Comments
Post a Comment
Please read our comment policy before commenting.